Beyond the Middleman: Building a Multi-Channel Playbook for Premium Brands

This blog is also available on Substack. Follow along there for addition insights into the artisanal spirits sector and supply chain technology.

From Theory to Practice: Implementing Distribution Transformation

In the companion piece to this article, we explored why premium wine and spirits brands are increasingly questioning their dependency on traditional distribution models. The economic, strategic, and technological forces driving this shift are compelling, but they raise an equally important question: what specifically are brands doing instead?

This article provides a practical examination of the alternative distribution approaches global brands are implementing, the operational requirements for success, and the results they're achieving. Rather than abstract possibilities, we'll focus on concrete strategies already being deployed by forward-thinking producers.

The insights shared here come from direct conversations with brand leaders implementing these changes, data from platforms facilitating alternative approaches, and analysis of brands that have successfully navigated this transition. While the traditional three-tier system remains important, understanding these emerging alternatives is becoming essential for any premium brand's long-term strategy.

The New Distribution Ecosystem: More Options Than You Think

Just as travelers today choose between booking directly with airlines, using aggregators like Expedia, or working with specialized travel advisors for complex trips, spirits brands are discovering a spectrum of options beyond the traditional distributor relationship.

The most successful brands aren't simply abandoning traditional distribution—they're strategically orchestrating multiple approaches based on specific market needs and brand objectives. Here's how this new ecosystem breaks down:

1. Enhanced Traditional Distribution: Teaching Old Dogs New Tricks

Think of this like the evolution of forward-thinking travel agents who survived the internet revolution. They didn't fight online booking—they evolved to provide specialized value beyond simple transaction processing.

Similarly, some brands are fundamentally restructuring their distributor relationships with:

• Performance-based incentives: Replacing standard margin structures with incentives tied to specific brand-building objectives
• Selective market participation: Using traditional distribution only where it demonstrably outperforms alternatives
• Enhanced data sharing: Requiring customer-level insights as a condition of partnership
• Brand control mechanisms: Maintaining direct oversight of brand ambassador programs and key account relationships

As the marketing director for a premium Champagne house explained to me: "It's like we renegotiated our relationship with a long-term contractor. They're still valuable partners, but the terms of engagement have fundamentally changed to reflect our growing brand equity."

2. Specialized Partner Networks: Unbundling the Bundle

Consider how many people now book flights directly with airlines, accommodations through Airbnb, and local experiences through specialized platforms—replacing the bundled services of a travel agent with more specialized providers.

Similarly, many spirits brands are replacing single full-service distributors with networks of specialized partners:

• Logistics specialists handling physical distribution without sales responsibilities
• Compliance platforms managing regulatory requirements
• Brand ambassador networks driving education and advocacy
• Sales representation firms providing account relationships without inventory requirements

One craft whiskey producer described their transition: "We realized distributors are basically a bundle of services—some valuable, some overpriced. So we unbundled them, keeping what worked and replacing what didn't. It's like canceling cable TV to subscribe only to the streaming services you actually watch."

3. Digital Marketplace Platforms: The Expedia of Spirits

Just as travel aggregators like Expedia and Booking.com connected consumers directly with hotels and airlines, new digital platforms are connecting spirits producers directly with retailers and on-premise accounts.

These marketplaces provide:

• Producer verification and discovery
• Digital compliance management
• Transaction facilitation
• Logistics coordination

Platforms like Maguey Exchange have demonstrated this model's viability with over 500 verified producers and technology that reduces the producer-to-market timeline from 6+ months to just 30 days.

A bar owner who uses these platforms told me: "It's like the difference between shopping at a department store versus a specialized online marketplace. I find products I'd never see through distributors, get better information directly from producers, and often pay less because there's one fewer entity taking margin."

4. Direct-to-Consumer Relationships: The Brand Connection

Think about how Airbnb hosts build direct relationships with guests, often creating repeat business without needing the platform for subsequent bookings.

Similarly, while regulatory constraints remain in alcohol, brands are finding increasingly sophisticated ways to build direct consumer connections:

• Brand home experiences that generate both immediate sales and long-term loyalty
• Membership programs offering exclusive access and experiences
• Content platforms that build relationships independent of purchase opportunities
• Strategic e-commerce where regulations permit

These approaches aren't just about immediate sales—they're about establishing direct consumer relationships that reduce dependency on third-party retail channels.

The Operational Requirements for Success

If you're considering revamping your distribution approach, understanding the required capabilities is essential. It's like deciding to handle your own investments instead of using a financial advisor—you need the right tools and knowledge to succeed.

Model 1: Capability Requirements by Distribution Approach

Source: Analysis of implementation requirements for alternative distribution approaches, 2023-2025

The Reality Check: Each approach requires specific capabilities that many wine and spirits brands haven't traditionally built. As one industry consultant put it: "It's like deciding to renovate your house yourself—you need to either develop new skills or hire specialists who already have them."

The most successful brands develop these capabilities through a combination of strategic hiring, technology investment, and carefully selected partnerships. A CFO at a rapidly-growing spirits brand explained their approach: "We mapped out the capabilities we'd need, then made build-versus-buy decisions for each one. Some we developed internally, others we partnered for, but we had a clear plan for every requirement."

Case Study: The Multi-Channel Orchestration Approach

The experience of a premium craft spirits portfolio (anonymized as "Altitude Spirits" for this article) demonstrates how these approaches can be strategically integrated to create a cohesive distribution strategy.

Altitude began as a traditionally distributed craft spirits producer with a portfolio of premium products across multiple categories. By 2022, they recognized the limitations of their distribution-dependent approach:

• Distributor consolidation had reduced their priority in key markets
• Their margins were compressed by standard distributor economics
• They lacked direct relationships with key consumers and accounts
• Their brand story was inconsistently communicated through distributor sales teams

Rather than making an abrupt shift, they implemented a phased transformation:

Phase 1: Distribution Enhancement (Months 1-6)

• Renegotiated distributor agreements in key markets to include performance metrics
• Implemented data sharing requirements with existing distributors
• Deployed their own brand ambassador team to supplement distributor sales efforts

Phase 2: Capability Development (Months 4-12)

• Built an internal direct-to-trade team for key account management
• Developed compliance management systems to reduce regulatory dependency
• Created content and experience platforms to drive direct consumer engagement
• Implemented performance tracking systems for all channels

Phase 3: Multi-Channel Integration (Months 10-24)

• Maintained enhanced traditional distribution in efficient markets
• Shifted to specialized partner networks in markets where traditional distribution underperformed
• Joined digital marketplace platforms to reach accounts outside traditional distribution strength
• Expanded DTC operations where regulations permitted

The results demonstrate the power of this orchestrated approach:

• Overall revenue increased 85% over the two-year implementation period
• Gross margin improved from 42% to 58% through more efficient channel economics
• Direct account relationships (managed outside traditional distribution) grew from 5% to 40% of total business
• Brand awareness metrics improved 115% through more consistent messaging and experiences

Crucially, Altitude didn't simply abandon traditional distribution—they integrated it within a broader multi-channel strategy that deployed each approach where it created the most value.

The Numbers Don't Lie: The Economics of Multi-Channel Distribution

The shift toward multi-channel distribution isn't driven by ideology—it's supported by compelling economics showing the advantage of strategic channel diversification.

Model 2: The Financial Reality of Different Distribution Channels

Source: Analysis of channel economics for premium spirits brands, 2021-2025

Key Insight: While alternative distribution approaches generally enable higher margin capture and better data quality, they don't universally outperform traditional distribution on all metrics. The optimal channel mix depends on brand-specific priorities and market conditions.

This data explains why most successful brands are pursuing integrated approaches rather than wholesale channel shifts. Each channel offers distinct advantages that can be strategically leveraged as part of a comprehensive go-to-market strategy.

When Traditional Distribution Still Makes Sense: A Balanced Perspective

Despite the compelling case for alternative approaches, traditional distribution remains advantageous in specific circumstances. To ignore this would be like claiming no one should ever use a travel agent—clearly untrue for complex group travel, specialized destinations, or travelers who value convenience over cost.

Several scenarios where traditional distribution continues to deliver superior results:

1. Volume-Driven Categories: For brands competing primarily on availability and price, traditional distribution's efficiency in physical placement often remains unmatched.
2. Limited Internal Capabilities: If you lack the organizational capacity to manage multiple relationships and technologies, the "one-stop" nature of traditional distribution may be more effective despite its higher cost.
3. Rapids Expansion Plans: When aggressive geographic expansion is the priority, distributors' existing account relationships can accelerate placement in ways difficult to replicate independently.

The key insight isn't that traditional distribution is obsolete, but rather that it should be deployed selectively where its specific advantages align with brand requirements—not as a default approach across all scenarios.

Model 3: Choosing the Right Channel for Your Objectives

Source: Channel selection framework based on primary brand objectives, 2022-2025

The Key Insight: The optimal approach depends fundamentally on your specific objectives and circumstances rather than industry conventions or historical practices.

As one distribution strategist noted: "It's less about choosing one channel and more about orchestrating multiple channels—like a conductor bringing together different instruments to create a harmonious whole."

Getting Started: Your Practical Next Steps

For brands considering a strategic shift in distribution approach, several practical starting points can yield meaningful results without requiring wholesale transformation:

1. Conduct an honest value assessment of your current distribution relationships: Much like reviewing your monthly subscriptions, systematically evaluate what specific benefits you receive relative to the costs.
2. Identify your highest-potential direct relationships: Which key accounts or consumers would benefit most from direct engagement? This is like identifying which friends you should definitely make time to see in person versus keeping up with on social media.
3. Start small and learn by doing: Implement pilot programs for alternative approaches in specific markets before broader rollout. It's the distribution equivalent of trying a meal kit service before renovating your entire kitchen.
4. Invest in the right enabling capabilities: Build the specific skills and technologies required for your target distribution approaches. Like learning a new language before moving to another country, preparation is essential for success.

The bar manager of a nationally acclaimed cocktail program described his experience with brands making this transition: "The ones that succeed don't make grand pronouncements about abandoning distributors—they quietly build alternative capabilities, test different approaches, and scale what works. It's evolutionary, not revolutionary."

What's Next: The Future of Spirits Distribution

Looking ahead, two key trends will reshape distribution for premium wine and spirits brands:

Trend 1: The Rise of the Orchestrators The most successful brands will develop sophisticated capabilities to manage multiple distribution channels simultaneously—strategically deploying each approach where it creates maximum value. It's like how savvy travelers might use a specialized travel agent for a complex safari, book flights directly with airlines for better control, and use Airbnb for unique accommodations—all for the same trip.

Trend 2: The Value of Direct Relationships Regardless of which distribution approaches brands employ, direct relationships with consumers and key accounts will become increasingly valuable strategic assets. Even brands that maintain significant traditional distribution will invest in building these direct connections. It's similar to how many retailers now operate both through Amazon's marketplace and their own direct channels simultaneously.

As one spirits industry investor recently told me: "Five years from now, we won't be talking about 'traditional versus alternative distribution'—we'll be evaluating brands on how effectively they orchestrate multiple channels to create maximum value. The winners will be those who master this complexity rather than clinging to simplistic either/or thinking."

Questions to Consider

As you evaluate your own distribution strategy, consider these questions:

1. What specific value does each element of your current distribution approach deliver relative to its cost?
2. Which markets or customer segments might benefit most from alternative approaches?
3. What capabilities would you need to develop to implement a more diverse distribution strategy?
4. How might direct relationships with key customers change your business beyond simple economics?
5. What does your ideal distribution mix look like three years from now?

The answers will vary for every brand, but asking these questions is essential for anyone looking to thrive in the spirits industry's next chapter.